
This man is beautiful.
This woman is not.

So the question remains,
Nioxin or
Rogaine? I admit, I tried both. My case is not as bad as the two examples above, but I have been dealing with hair loss or thinning hair since my Accutane days. I didn't discuss on my Acne post but my acne was so bad that I did two rounds of Accutane with great facial skin results. I say facial because it actually destroyed my liver and kidneys. Accutane is extremely harmful and now women need to take a pregnancy test monthly and do blood tests just to make sure that you're not slowly dying (with great skin). It's super high dose of Vitamin A which is not a water soluble vitamin. Too much of anything is bad, lesson learned. Anyway, part of the side affect was hair loss for me. It's not very noticeable, but I also don't have the sex appeal of having a full bodied hair. Seriously, if you take close look at some women who you perceive as HOT, they really might not be, it might just be their nice head of hair. You will rarely find female celebrities with too little or thinning hair. It just doesn't complete the package without the big flowy hair.
So, Nioxin. First, read what I found as a review below:
5.0 out of 5 stars It works, March 30, 2009
By D. Childs (Northeastern USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)
I am 49 and have been using this Nioxin products for as long as the
company has been around. I have a full head of hair. My brother
sneered at my use of this product 20 years ago but he has since gone
completely bald.
Another lesson learned. Listen to your siblings. They will tell you when you are balding.
Nioxin comes in 8 different "systems." I will only mention the ones that are not for chemically enhanced hair because you really shouldn't be doing that if you're balding anyway.

System 1: For Fine, Natural, Normal to Thin-Looking Hair
System 2: For Fine, Natural, Noticeably Thinning Hair
System 5: For Medium/Coarse, Natural, Normal to Thin-Looking Hair
system 6: For Medium/Coarse, Natural, Noticeably Thinning Hair
For systems 5 and 6 the website has a picture of black people. That's a side note. I've met plenty of Asians with coarse hair so since this blog aims to be racially sensitive, I thought I should add that.
Rogaine comes in two strengths: for men and women. FDA believed that women should not be using the strength as for men, but my dermatologist assured that it's ok now. Still, just to be safe, I would stick with the women Rx if you're a woman so that you can sue the company if something happens to you.
That being said, Rogaine really made my scalp itch. I used to faithfully for about 2 months and then all of a sudden I woke up 3 nights in a row because my scalp was so itchy! Once I discontinued using it the itchiness stopped. Maybe it's a sign that it's working but if you're scratching your head in the middle of the night, then first, your partner will no longer be attracted to you, and second, you might scratch all your hair off.
Rogaine is also a little difficult to use. The application tip kind of hurts.
So my pick is Nioxin. It has a nice pepperminty scent and I saw a noticeable difference in the amount of hair that no longer falls off. Even if you're not noticeably thinning, I think this shampoo and conditioner system is very good quality. I would recommend purchasing the large bottles on Amazon. They're pricier than like Pantene or Pert Plus or whatever you use, but if you think about the money you'll save on hair transplants, then it's worth it. Chump change.